What Does The Term “Mens Rea” Mean?
Wednesday, April 30th, 2008Many people wonder how the law distinguishes between someone who deliberately set out to cause harm to someone and an action that accidentally resulted in harm.
There is an old Latin term used in the law, particularly criminal law, that is called “mens rea.” Mens rea (pronounced, menz ray uh) means “guilty mind” and is a concept present in most criminal laws that distinguishes between an accidental event and an intentional act, even if they both result in the same harm caused to someone’s life, person or property.
For example, a defendant who is on trial for murder must be shown to have not only caused the death of another, but also shown to have intended to commit an unlawful act. Notice that the state does not have to prove that the defendant intended to cause a person’s death, but that the intent was to do something that was against the law.
This means that if someone’s death resulted from a defendant’s actions while in the act of committing a robbery, the intent to break the law for a robbery is carried over to the death of the victim.
Recklessness is also a mens rea. For example, if a defendant was driving at high speeds through a residential neighborhood and a death occurs as a result, that criminal recklessness is sufficient recklessness for a charge of manslaughter.
Traditional, most criminal statutes required some level of moral culpability in order to find a defendant guilty. For example, suppose a hunter is charged with murder after accidentally shooting another hunter while out in the woods during hunting season. If the shooter’s